Hailey Bieber has found herself at the center of yet another social media controversy, 

with a TikTok creator alleging that she “liked” a post mocking her husband Justin Bieber’s ex-girlfriend, Selena Gomez, and Gomez’s fiancé, Benny Blanco.

The claim has reignited long-standing speculation about tensions between the two women, despite repeated public assurances that they have no ongoing feud.

Allegations of Social Media Shade

A TikTok user, known as @courtneypresto, recently shared a video in which she accused Hailey of interacting with a post that ridiculed Gomez

and Blanco’s photoshoot for Interview Magazine. The original post, created by the TikTokker herself,

featured a series of images from the couple’s shoot, accompanied by text that read, “I genuinely can’t decide which is the worst.”

In the video, the social media user expressed her belief that Hailey’s alleged “like” was a sign that the supposed drama between her and Gomez was far from over. “I feel like this is definitive proof that, when Hailey Bieber says, ‘Oh, it’s all love, we have no beef, everything is fine,’ she’s lying,” the TikTokker claimed.

However, Hailey’s representatives quickly shut down the allegations, stating, “This never happened. This entire story has been fabricated by a content creator looking to capitalize off of an old, tired narrative.”

A History of Speculation and Feud Rumors

Hailey and Selena have been pitted against each other for years due to their romantic connections with Justin Bieber. The pop star and Gomez had an on-again, off-again relationship spanning nearly a decade, from 2010 to 2018. Just months after their final breakup, Justin moved on with Hailey, proposing to her in July 2018. The couple tied the knot in September of the same year, further fueling speculation that there was tension between Hailey and Gomez.

Despite years of fan speculation about a rivalry, both women have publicly denied any animosity. In a 2022 interview on the Call Her Daddy podcast, Hailey insisted that she and Gomez shared mutual “respect” and “love” and that there was no lingering drama.

In an apparent effort to prove there were no hard feelings, Hailey even “liked” Gomez’s Instagram post announcing her engagement to Benny Blanco in December 2024, seemingly signaling support for the couple.

Social Media Scrutiny

While both Hailey and Selena have spoken out against the ongoing speculation about their relationship, their every online move continues to be dissected by fans. Whether it’s a liked post, a cryptic comment, or a new social media follow, the internet is quick to analyze and assign meaning to their interactions.

In this latest instance, the alleged “like” from Hailey has only reignited discussions about the supposed tension between her and Gomez. The fact that her representatives swiftly denied the claim suggests an attempt to shut down the controversy before it gains further traction.

Meanwhile, Gomez has largely stayed silent on the matter, continuing to focus on her relationship with Blanco. The Only Murders in the Building star confirmed her romance with the music producer in December 2023, and the couple has been openly affectionate on social media ever since.

The Bigger Picture

This is far from the first time that Hailey and Selena’s names have been dragged into online drama. Fans on both sides have often fueled speculation, with social media interactions frequently interpreted as subtle jabs or passive-aggressive gestures.

However, both women have expressed exhaustion over the narrative and have attempted to shut down rumors multiple times. Despite this, the internet’s fascination with their dynamic continues.

As Hailey and Justin settle into their new chapter as parents—the couple welcomed their first child, Jack Blues Bieber, in August 2024—it remains to be seen whether these longstanding feud rumors will ever fully die down.

For now, Hailey’s representatives have made it clear that she was not involved in this latest social media scandal, but that hasn’t stopped fans from continuing to speculate on whether the alleged drama between her and Gomez is truly in the past.